| 8/18/23 | Fri | 10:00 AM | Away | Petoskey (Petoskey Northmen Classic) | WIN (1-0) |
| 8/18/23 | Fri | 11:30 AM | Away | Lake Orion (Petoskey Northmen Classic) | Lose (2-4) |
| 8/18/23 | Fri | 1:00 PM | Away | Oxford (Petoskey Northmen Classic) | Lose (2-3) |
| 8/19/23 | Sat | 1:00 PM | Away | Traverse City Christian | WIN (3-2) |
| 8/30/23 | Wed | 5:00 PM | Home | Iron Mountain | WIN (6-0) |
| 9/5/23 | Tue | 6:00 PM | Away | Kingsford | Lose (1-3) |
| 9/7/23 | Thu | 5:00 PM | Home | Sault Ste. Marie | WIN (5-0) |
| 9/12/23 | Tue | 6:00 PM | Home | Houghton | WIN (7-0) |
| 9/16/23 | Sat | 10:30 AM | Away | Gaylord (Suttons Bay Invite) | WIN (1-0) |
| 9/16/23 | Sat | 12:00 PM | Away | Harbor Springs (Suttons Bay Invite) | WIN (2-0) |
| 9/16/23 | Sat | 1:30 PM | Away | Kalkaska (Suttons Bay Invite) | WIN (6-1) |
| 9/19/23 | Tue | 6:00 PM | Away | Iron Mountain | WIN (4-2) |
| 9/26/23 | Tue | 6:00 PM | Home | Kingsford | Lose (0-1) |
| 10/4/23 | Wed | 5:00 PM | Away | Sault Ste. Marie | WIN (7-0) |
| 10/7/23 | Sat | 12:00 PM | Home | Iron Mountain (U.P. Tournament) | WIN (6-1) |
| 10/7/23 | Sat | 2:00 PM | Home | Kingsford (U.P. Tournament) | Lose (1-1; 2-3 Shootout) |
| 10/17/23 | Tue | 5:00 PM | Home | Alpena (MHSAA District Semifinal) | WIN (3-0) |
| 10/21/23 | Sat | 1:00 PM | Home | Petoskey (MHSAA District Final) | WIN (1-1; 8-7 Shootout) |
| 10/24/23 | Tue | 5:00 PM | Away | Fruitport (MHSAA Regional Semifinal at Gaylord) | Lose (0-2) |
